CATEGORIES
Look Who's Linking to PoliBlog:
3cx.org
Absinthe and Cookies
Accidental Verbosity
Admiral Quixote's Roundtable
All Day Permanent Red
All Things Jennifer
Ann Althouse
The American Mind
Arguing with signposts
Arms and influence
The Astute Blogger
Asymmeterical Information
Attaboy
augustus
B-Town Blog Boys
BabyTrollBlog
Backcountry Conservative
Balloon Juice
Bananas and Such Begging to Differ
The Bemusement Park
Benedict
Bewtween the Coasts
Betsy's Page
The Big Picture
BipolarBBSBlog
BIZBLOGGER
bLogicus
Blogs for Bush
The Blog of Daniel Sale
BoiFromTroy
Boots and Sabers
brykMantra
BushBlog
The Bully Pulpit
Cadillac Tight
Caffeinated Musing
California Yankee
Captain's Quarters
Chicago Report
Chicagoland of Confusion
Citizen Smash
Coldheartedtruth
Collected Thoughts
The Command Post
Common Sense and Wonder
Confessions Of A Political Junkie
The Conservative Philosopher
Conservative Revolution
Conservative and Right
Cranial Cavity
The Daily Lemon
Daly Thoughts
DANEgerus Weblog
Dart Frog on a Cactus
Dean's World Dear Free World
Brad DeLong
Democracy Project
DiVERSiONZ
The Disagreeable Conservative Curmudgeon
Down to the Piraeus
Drink this...
Earl's log
Earthly Passions
The Education Wonks
the evangelical outpost
exvigilare
Eye of the Storm
Feste
Filtrat
Firepower Forward
The Flying Space Monkey Chronicles
The Friendly Ghost
FringeBlog
Fruits and Votes
Functional, if not decorative
G-Blog.net
The Galvin Opinion
The Glittering Eye
Haight Speech
Half-Bakered
The Hedgehog Report
Heh. Indeed.
Hellblazer
Hennessy's View
High Desert Skeptic
The Hillary Project
History and Perceptions
Robert Holcomb
I love Jet Noise
Idlewild South
Incommunicado
Independent Thinker
Insults Unpunished
Interested-Participant
Internet Ronin
Ipse Dixit
It Can't Rain All The Time...
The Jay Blog
Jen Speaks
Joefish's Freshwater Blog
John Lemon
johnrpierce.info blog
Judicious Asininity
Jump In, The Water's Fine!
Just On The Other Side
KeepinItReal
A Knight's Blog
The Kudzu Files
LeatherPenguin
Let's Try Freedom
LibertarianJackass.com
Liberty Father
Life and Law
David Limbaugh
LittleBugler
Locke, or Demosthenes?
LostINto
Mad Minerva
Gary Manca
Mark the Pundit
Mediocre but Unexciting
memeorandum
Mental Hiccups
Miller's Time
Mind of Mog
Minorities For Bush
Mr. Hawaii
The Moderate Voice
The Modulator
Much Ado
Mungowitz End
My opinion counts
my thoughts, without the penny charge
My Word
mypetjawa
Naw
Neophyte Pundit
Neutiquam erro
New England Republican
NewsHawk Daily
neWs Round-Up
NixGuy.com
No Pundit Intended
Nobody asked me, but...
Obsidian Wings
Occam's Toothbrush
On the Fritz
On the Third Hand
One Fine Jay
Out of Context
Outside the Beltway
Suman Palit
Parablemania
Passionate America
Brian Patton
Peaktalk
Pelicanpost
Peppermint Patty
Phlegma
John Pierce
PiratesCove
Politicalman
The Politicker
The Politburo Diktat
Political Annotation
Political Blog For The Politically Incorrect
Possumblog
Power Politics
Powerpundit.com
Practical Penumbra
Priorities & Frivolities ProfessorBainbridge.com
Prof. Blogger's Pontifications
Pros and Cons
protein wisdom
PunditFilter
Pundit Heads
QandO
The Queen of All Evil
Quotes, Thoughts, and other Ramblings
Ramblings' Journal
Random Acts of Kindness
Random Nuclear Strikes
Ranting Rationalist
Read My Lips
Reagan Country
Red State Diaries
Jay Reding.com
A Republican's Blog
Resource.full
The Review
Rhett Write
Right Side of the Rainbow
Right Wingin-It
Right Wing News
Right Voices
Rightward Reasonings
riting on the wall
robwestcott
Rooftop Report
RoguePundit
The Sake of Argument
Sailor in the Desert
Scrappleface
Secular Sermons
Sha Ka Ree
Shaking Spears
She Who Will Be Obeyed!
The Skeptician
The Skewed
Slant/Point.
Slobokan's Site O' Schtuff
small dead animals
Sneakeasy's Joint
SoCal Law Blog
A Solo Dialogue
Solomonia
Some Great Reward
Southern Musings
Speed of Thought...
Spin Killer
Matthew J. Stinson
A Stitch in Haste
Stop the ACLU
The Strange Political Road Trip of Jane Q. Public
The Strata-Sphere
Stuff about
Suman Palit
SwimFinsSF
Target Centermass
Templar Pundit
The Temporal Globe
Tex the Pontificator
Texas Native
think about it...
Tiger
Tobacco Road Fogey
Toner Mishap
Tony Talks Tech
The Trimblog
Truth. Quante-fied.
Twenty First Century Republican
Unlocked Wordhoard
Use The Forks!!
Ut Humiliter Opinor
Varifrank
VietPundit
Vista On Current Events
VodkaPundit
Vox Baby
Jeff Vreeland's Blog
Wall of Sleep
Weapons of Mass Discussion
Who Knew?
The Window Manager
Winning Again!
WizBang!
WizBang Tech
The World Around You
The Yin Blog
You Big Mouth, You!
Zygote-Design
al.com - Alabama Weblogs

AJC's 2004 Election Politics Sites and Blogs
Campaign Finance
Welcome to newcounterculture.com World O' Blogs
WRKO-AM's "Political Junkies" list
Yahoo! Directory Political Weblogs
Young Elephant

Who Links Here

Thursday, May 12, 2005
Yet More on Immigration
By Dr. Steven Taylor @ 10:43 am

The immigration exchange continues between myself and the denizens of Pros and Cons.

Scott Gosnell weighs in, and raises the issue of dealing the underlying incentives that draw immigrants to the US. As a generic point, I wholly concur that dealing with incentive structures is a key may to affect behavior. He further rightly notes that a more efficacious approach would be to punish those who hire illegals. As a side note: the incentives that need the most addressing are finding ways to spur economic grow in Mexico, so that leaving won’t be as attractive.

He also addresses the incentive issue as follows:

Also, illegals should be entitled to no benefits. If you’re injured, tough — no hospital care. No driver’s license. No education. No welfare. No nothing. No access to civil courts (note, I said civil courts). If you manage to sneak into the United States illegally, you do so at your own risk.

An analogy (imperfect, I grant you): a Wyoming corporation is required to register as a foreign corporation before it can do business in Alabama. If it fails to do so, it can still do business in Alabama, but if it get’s screwed on a contract or has some sort of civil complaint or cause of action, it has no access to Alabama courts — it is essentially an illegal alien.

Now, I understand the underlying logic, and it has a certain amount of appeal. However, let’s consider the hospital issue. For one thing, if a guy comes in on a stretcher after a traffic accident, how in Heaven’s name will the doctors know if the guy is an illegal alien, a legal one, a resident, or a citizen? Further, are we really going to advocate pushing the gurney in the corner and letting the guy die if we find out that he’s illegal? There are moral and basic human rights issues here. Further, I would think that such actions would violate the fundaments of the medical profession.

Certainly, I can see no justification for welfare payments or the issuing of drivers licenses to illegals. Of course, there is the sticky problem of the mother who is illegal, yet her child is an American citizen (that whole 14th Amendment thing). It is rather difficult not to give her assistance.

Indeed, all this gets to the real fundamental problem: we are dealing with human being here, and primarily decent human beings who are simply trying to better their own circumstances.

Along these lines a discussion ensues between Scott and fellow P&Cer Doug Flinn, who notes Jesus’ admonition to feed the poor and such. Scott responds with a discussion of personal responsibilities v. those of government. I take his point to a point, but given that government is nothing more that a reflection of collected individuals (certainly true in a democracy, at any rate), I am not sure that his logic holds—especially since what his policy prescriptions could boil down to is individual action, as per the hospital example above.

Really, what all of this points out is the deep complexity of this issue and further underscores my visceral reaction to the Minuteman Project—as it reduced the whole problem to one of bodies on the border and the idea of interdicting those who cross. The problem is far more multifaceted than that.

On a side note, this interchange has underscored one of the great advantages of blogging—it helps me has out ideas. In this particular case it helps tease out in my own mind what it was about the MM that really caused read flags to wave in my head—it was less the “vigilante�? aspect of the situation, but rather the feeding of a popular mis-perception (often fed by Bill O’Reilly, amongst others) that the problem really is simple to solve, and it is just the lack of will in Washington to solve it that is the real problem.

Filed under: Immigration | |Send TrackBack

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

The trackback url for this post is: http://www.poliblogger.com/wp-trackback.php?p=7029

NOTE: I will delete any TrackBacks that do not actually link and refer to this post.

Leave a comment



Take a Look At This!
Inquiries
Blogroll


Visitors Since 2/15/03
---

PoliBlog is the Host site for:

A TTLB Community


Advertisement

Business Associates

Finance Answers

Health Benefits

Beach Homes

Car Shopping

Advertisement


Powered by WordPress